About this site

Who writes this site, on what basis, and how it relates to the practice.

This site is written and maintained by Dr Nicholas Taylor, Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist. Its purpose is to provide legal professionals with a rigorous, clinically informed and regularly updated account of the Pritchard criteria, the law of fitness to plead in England and Wales, and the procedure surrounding a finding of unfitness.

The author

  • Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist
  • MB ChB
  • Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists (FRCPsych)
  • LLM
  • Approved under section 12(2) of the Mental Health Act 1983

Dr Taylor accepts instructions in criminal proceedings, including instructions addressing fitness to plead and effective participation. His work combines specialist forensic psychiatric practice with formal legal training, with particular emphasis on translating psychiatric and cognitive findings into the functional questions the criminal court is required to determine. More information about his professional practice is available at drnicholastaylor.me.

Who the site is for

It is written for practitioners who need precision: the barrister preparing a fitness argument, the solicitor deciding whether to seek a report, the expert refining their approach, and the student or researcher who wants the test set out rigorously rather than in summary.

The practice

Instructions and preliminary enquiries are handled through Forensic Psychiatry Experts, Lion Court, Melbourne Road, Staunton Harold, Ashby-de-la-Zouch LE65 1RT. The practice accepts forensic psychiatric instructions across England and Wales, including assessments in custody, hospital and the community and, where clinically and procedurally appropriate, remotely. Details of the wider practice are available at forensicpsychiatryexperts.co.uk, and the information needed for a preliminary fitness-to-plead enquiry is set out on the Contact page.

Disclaimer

This site provides general professional information about the law and clinical assessment of fitness to plead. It is not legal advice and does not address the facts of any individual case. The law is fact-sensitive and may change. Case summaries on this site are necessarily selective and should not be relied upon in place of reading the judgments and legislation themselves. Anyone involved in criminal proceedings should obtain advice appropriate to the particular case from a qualified lawyer and, where necessary, a suitably qualified expert.

Written by Dr Nicholas Taylor, Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist. Last reviewed October 2026.

The test in depth

The case law

Where the test comes from, and an annotated digest of the authorities from Pritchard to the present.

Read the case law

Conditions and fitness

How intellectual disability, psychosis, autism, brain injury, dementia and mood disorders bear on the test.

Read conditions and fitness

Criticisms and reform

Why the test is criticised, what the Law Commission proposed, and where reform stands.

Read criticisms and reform

Request availability for a fitness-to-plead assessment

Preliminary enquiries are welcome before a decision to instruct has been taken. A short outline of the charge, court, next hearing date, defendant’s location, the nature of the concern, whether an existing psychiatric or psychological report is available, and the funding position is usually enough to establish whether an assessment is appropriate and what timescale is available.

contact@forensicpsychiatryexperts.co.uk

Or telephone 0116 380 5641.

Request availability